Now writing for PÚBLICO
There’s this guiding principle in journalism called the “inverted pyramid”, which dictates a writer should address the “Five Ws” of a story on the piece’s lead. Here’s a practical example: this September, I started collaborating with PÚBLICO — one of Portugal’s main newspapers, and certainly the one maintaining the best culture section — as a classical music critic.
That covers the when, the who, the what, and the where. The why is a thornier question.
Despite being rather opinionated, I’ve never had the slightest penchant for pushing my opinions out there — something I think is notable for someone whose teenage years coincided cleanly with the Web 2.0. Despite briefly maintaining a MySpace (and, judging by my current profession, having a higher-than-average engagement with music), I don’t think I was ever interested in the legendary profile music player. The only blog I had was, in fact, a short fiction experiment I quickly abandoned. Twitter was my stomping ground for about a decade, and I must’ve been the main character in my minute social circles about twice. Facebook might’ve had some sadposting disguised as music sharing, and that’s about it. I’ve just never been interested — I just don’t think that’s how a public sphere is supposed to work. I say things like “no investigation, no right to speak”, half-hoping nobody googles it, half-hoping they do. Besides: who cares? You can have my opinion if and when you pay for it.
And so a monkey’s paw curled a finger, because my bluff was called.
The flipside of this era of almost compulsive opinion-sharing is that I can do away with opinion per se — not because I don’t have them, but because I think they’re rather useless to the project of criticism today.
Art criticism has always helped different social groups become self-aware as a public. As Michael Newman argues in “The Specificity of Criticism and Its Need for Philosophy” in Elkins, J., & Newman, M. (eds.). (2007). The state of art criticism. Routledge, while the «bridge between the intimate, subjective response of the individual critic and the “general” public» might’ve been useful in its early days, the conditions underpinning that operativity were already liquidated by the nineteenth century, let alone in the twenty-first. «[I]t no longer makes sense to speak of a single public or a single public sphere», and one individual participates in more than one public.
To the likely chagrin of my editors, I’m almost wholly uninterested in criticism-as-witnessing, in saying what happened and how it happened — uninterested in the adjective, «the poorest of linguistic categories» when it comes to music criticism, as Barthes said in Le grain de la voix. It bears repeating: this is the twenty-first century, for godsakes — almost the entirety of public music-making is professionalized and mediated through various institutional, technical, technological apparatuses. There are very few failure modes for a work or a performance (if we allow ourselves to pretend for a moment that that’s what judgment in criticism means). When they do fail, ooh boy are they interesting: they invariably point out towards larger social — political — arrangements which have as much impact on our ability to constitute ourselves as a public around our dearest artworks as the music itself. Any criticism of culture should understand how meanings are woven into the social fabric, and how they come to organize our experience, not to measure practices against what they ought to be or ought to have been. Especially not when what they are is much more interesting. If my writing engenders a space where readers can connect in recognition to those around them (even if only in one paragraph every now and then), I’ll be happy.
All of this to say: I’m taking this occasion to open up a Writings page here on the website, collecting all of my published bits and bobs. I hadn’t really ever done the work of collecting them, and I might be forgetting some, but we have a starting point to watch them grow. Thank you for reading.