Media

Now writing for PÚBLICO

IMG 20260702 163120

There’s this guid­ing prin­ci­ple in jour­nal­ism called the ​“invert­ed pyra­mid”, which dic­tates a writer should address the ​“Five Ws” of a sto­ry on the piece’s lead. Here’s a prac­ti­cal exam­ple: this Sep­tem­ber, I start­ed col­lab­o­rat­ing with PÚBLI­CO — one of Por­tu­gal’s main news­pa­pers, and cer­tain­ly the one main­tain­ing the best cul­ture sec­tion — as a clas­si­cal music critic.

That cov­ers the when, the who, the what, and the where. The why is a thornier question.

Despite being rather opin­ion­at­ed, I’ve nev­er had the slight­est pen­chant for push­ing my opin­ions out there — some­thing I think is notable for some­one whose teenage years coin­cid­ed clean­ly with the Web 2.0. Despite briefly main­tain­ing a MySpace (and, judg­ing by my cur­rent pro­fes­sion, hav­ing a high­er-than-aver­age engage­ment with music), I don’t think I was ever inter­est­ed in the leg­endary pro­file music play­er. The only blog I had was, in fact, a short fic­tion exper­i­ment I quick­ly aban­doned. Twit­ter was my stomp­ing ground for about a decade, and I must’ve been the main char­ac­ter in my minute social cir­cles about twice. Face­book might’ve had some sad­post­ing dis­guised as music shar­ing, and that’s about it. I’ve just nev­er been inter­est­ed — I just don’t think that’s how a pub­lic sphere is sup­posed to work. I say things like ​“no inves­ti­ga­tion, no right to speak”, half-hop­ing nobody googles it, half-hop­ing they do. Besides: who cares? You can have my opin­ion if and when you pay for it.

And so a mon­key’s paw curled a fin­ger, because my bluff was called.

The flip­side of this era of almost com­pul­sive opin­ion-shar­ing is that I can do away with opin­ion per se — not because I don’t have them, but because I think they’re rather use­less to the project of crit­i­cism today.

Art crit­i­cism has always helped dif­fer­ent social groups become self-aware as a pub­lic. As Michael New­man argues in ​“The Speci­fici­ty of Crit­i­cism and Its Need for Phi­los­o­phy” in Elkins, J., & New­man, M. (eds.). (2007). The state of art crit­i­cism. Rout­ledge, while the «bridge between the inti­mate, sub­jec­tive response of the indi­vid­ual crit­ic and the ​“gen­er­al” pub­lic» might’ve been use­ful in its ear­ly days, the con­di­tions under­pin­ning that oper­a­tiv­i­ty were already liq­ui­dat­ed by the nine­teenth cen­tu­ry, let alone in the twen­ty-first. «[I]t no longer makes sense to speak of a sin­gle pub­lic or a sin­gle pub­lic sphere», and one indi­vid­ual par­tic­i­pates in more than one public.

To the like­ly cha­grin of my edi­tors, I’m almost whol­ly unin­ter­est­ed in crit­i­cism-as-wit­ness­ing, in say­ing what hap­pened and how it hap­pened — unin­ter­est­ed in the adjec­tive, «the poor­est of lin­guis­tic cat­e­gories» when it comes to music crit­i­cism, as Barthes said in Le grain de la voix. It bears repeat­ing: this is the twen­ty-first cen­tu­ry, for god­sakes — almost the entire­ty of pub­lic music-mak­ing is pro­fes­sion­al­ized and medi­at­ed through var­i­ous insti­tu­tion­al, tech­ni­cal, tech­no­log­i­cal appa­ra­tus­es. There are very few fail­ure modes for a work or a per­for­mance (if we allow our­selves to pre­tend for a moment that that’s what judg­ment in crit­i­cism means). When they do fail, ooh boy are they inter­est­ing: they invari­ably point out towards larg­er social — polit­i­cal — arrange­ments which have as much impact on our abil­i­ty to con­sti­tute our­selves as a pub­lic around our dear­est art­works as the music itself. Any crit­i­cism of cul­ture should under­stand how mean­ings are woven into the social fab­ric, and how they come to orga­nize our expe­ri­ence, not to mea­sure prac­tices against what they ought to be or ought to have been. Espe­cial­ly not when what they are is much more inter­est­ing. If my writ­ing engen­ders a space where read­ers can con­nect in recog­ni­tion to those around them (even if only in one para­graph every now and then), I’ll be happy.

All of this to say: I’m tak­ing this occa­sion to open up a Writ­ings page here on the web­site, col­lect­ing all of my pub­lished bits and bobs. I had­n’t real­ly ever done the work of col­lect­ing them, and I might be for­get­ting some, but we have a start­ing point to watch them grow. Thank you for reading.